Friday, 25 January 2013

Should we forget about financial speculation and food prices?

By Stephen Spratt

"Speculators may do no harm as bubbles on a steady stream of enterprise. But the situation is serious when enterprise becomes the bubble on a whirlpool of speculation.” 
John Maynard Keynes

On Wednesday the IF campaign was launched in the UK by a group of 100 NGOs. Timed to coincide with the UK’s Presidency of the G8, the campaign seeks to address the causes of global hunger. The focus will be on four areas:
  • finance for small-scale farming and maternal and child nutrition
  • land grabs and biofuel production
  • tax evasion
  • government transparency.
These are clearly vitally important issues for dealing with global hunger and malnutrition, and the campaign deserves real credit and support for trying to get at underlying causes rather than concentrating on symptoms.

What is also interesting, however, is what is not there. The campaign addresses the problem of high and volatile global food prices through land-use – i.e. reducing both ‘land grabs’ and biofuel production to increase the supply of food.

Not so long ago, however, the influence of financial speculation on food prices would also have figured prominently in many people’s list of ‘villains’. The fact that this is not so implies that this is no longer a problem, or perhaps never was. Should we forget about this issue then?

I would suggest that the answer is no: while the case is not proven, the jury is still out.

Food prices
2012 saw the worst drought in 50 years in the United States. Other major food producers also experienced an unusually dry year, severely affecting harvests. As prices began to move upwards last summer, many predicted a price ‘spike’ like those seen in 2008 and 2010. In an attempt to avert this, the French President called a meeting of the G20 Agriculture Ministers for mid-October under the banner of the Rapid Response Forum (RRF), established after the last price spike.

Rather than continuing to rise as expected, however, the prices of key food commodities either stayed flat or were falling by September. Some pointed to the role played by the new Agricultural Market Information System (AMIS) in providing accurate information on supply conditions, arguing that this prevented markets becoming spooked. Major producing countries did not impose export bans, and the chunk of the harvest gobbled up by biofuels was also less than in previous years. Collective sighs of relief were heard. The crisis was averted. The emergency RRF meeting was cancelled as ‘it was unnecessary’ – food commodity markets were, we were told, ‘functioning well’.

Financial controls
2012 also saw the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) seek to impose restrictions on financial ‘speculation’ in food markets. The focus was the introduction of ‘position limits’, which limit the proportion of the market that can be held by any one institution. Although the limit still allowed up to a quarter of the market to be so controlled, it was still met with fierce lobbying from the financial sector. This culminated in a Federal District Court judgement in September, which went against the CFTC. The ruling was that the CFTC needed to show that position limits were needed to reduce market instability and volatility, and had failed to do so.

For some, we can relax: measures taken after the last food crisis work – those who had predicted a crisis in 2012 were wrong; critics who suggested that the huge increase in financial speculation in commodity futures markets in the last decade had driven up the level and volatility of prices were also wrong; all that was needed for markets to work well was better information (i.e. AMIS) and coordination to prevent things like export bans (i.e. the RRF). Controls on financial speculation were unnecessary and likely to be counterproductive: far from increasing volatility and moving prices away from ‘fair values’, speculators stabilise markets by increasing liquidity, and aid ‘price discovery’ by buying undervalued, and selling overvalued, assets.

While some accept this view in its entirety, most are less sanguine. The CFTC is appealing against the court ruling, arguing that position limits are designed to prevent market manipulation, which is crucial for markets to function properly. The European Union plans to implement a similar measure in its review of the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID) . Outside of the financial lobby, almost everyone agrees that controls on the ability of institutions to exert too large an influence – and potentially manipulate – markets are desirable. Others would go further.

If one thinks, for example, that markets are prone to periodic bouts of ‘irrationality’ – even with good information, and in the absence of abuse – further measures are likely to be required. In September 2012, for example, Members of the European Parliament voted to impose short delays on computerised, high frequency trading in food commodity markets, arguing that this kind of trading is likely to increase volatility. Others, such as the World Development Movement (WDM) , have called for the total amount of financial ‘speculation’ in the market to be restricted. The argument is the same as that used by Keynes in the quote at the start of this article: too much financial speculation relative to trading based on ‘real’ economic activity is likely to destabilise markets.

The UN’s Special Rapporteur on The Right to Food made a similar argument in 2010:
A significant contributory cause of the price spike was speculation by institutional investors who did not have any expertise or interest in agricultural commodities, and who invested in commodities index funds because other financial markets had dried up, or in order to hedge speculative bets made on those markets.
In a series of papers, UNCTAD have pointed to the increasing correlation between commodity prices and those of other financial assets. Ten years ago, there was little relationship between movements in European stock markets, the price of crude oil in the US, and a global diversified commodity price index. The picture today is very different:
...the financialization of commodity markets reveals a dramatic change. Despite the similarities in 2002 and 2012 in terms of real shocks – insecurity in West Asia, the aftermath of a stock market crash and a difficult cereals harvest – the evolution of the three indices could not be more different. Ten years ago each market had its own dynamics, but in 2012 they are moving in nearly perfect tandem.
UNCTAD’s point is subtle but important. Rather than being driven by supply and demand conditions in the real economy, food prices are increasingly determined by events in other markets. The common factor is finance.

So who is right, and does it matter? 
Despite the circumstantial evidence, it has not been possible to prove a link between increased speculation in food futures markets and spot market prices. People who work in these markets, however, are generally in no doubt that such a link exists. Even if there was a link, however, would this be a problem? Well, this comes back to your view of how financial markets work. Financial speculators could help stabilise market prices around ‘fair values’ that accurately reflect economic fundamentals, or they could increase volatility and drive prices away from these values.

On this question, the evidence presented in my recent paper, Food price volatility and financial speculation, suggests that UNCTAD may be right: the risk of heightened volatility and inaccurate price signals resulting from the financialisation of food markets is very real, even if markets appear to be working well today. After all, before the crisis of 2008 there was much talk of how sophisticated and efficient global financial markets had become, and how market prices could now instantly adjust to accurately reflect changing ‘economic realities.’

The final question is whether more volatile or inaccurate prices matter much. Here the answer is clear. Food markets are different to other financial markets. Stable prices that send accurate signals are of fundamental importance to the lives of billions. Set against this, the ‘costs’ of placing some curbs on speculation, which in the end may be no more than a reduction in the profitability of some financial institutions, are trivial. 

157 comments :

Nathan Oxley said...

You can download Stephen's working paper here:

http://www.future-agricultures.org/publications/research-and-analysis/working-papers/doc_download/1610-food-price-volatility-and-financial-speculation

Lewis N. Clark said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Steve said...

Technically very well above you said betonyvernon

Mohamed alex said...

Its very useful if every one should follow this cistartupcamp

Evita Kiley said...

Its very useful if every one should follow this. emersondameron

Evita Kiley said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
vaishno devi said...

Peoples are giving the wonderful thoughts for all comments
CuraLoop

Thirsha said...

Keep posting the articles,useful to every one thepopsucker

rithika said...

Really good one,every should like this.
bayiv

Liza Rene said...

Simply super comments are posted here.
ndnspeechmom

saran rajkumar said...

Its very useful if every one should follow this
sensecreator

Harish Dev said...

Thanks for giving the good informative tutorial
msgcfitness

hollyjpepper said...

Nice work,keep going moosenoose

John Joeban said...


Keep posting the articles,useful to every one.
kinograph

Charlie Ila said...

Thanks for giving the good informative tutorial
thesheltermovie

Mohamed said...

Simply super comments are posted here sqmyxx

Rajini said...

Awesome ideas are given here…!
ArchSport

Jambari Juma said...


Nice post. Every one should implement this one. lbgzs

Moha said...

Nice post. Every one should implement this one babyminding

Irfan Shamira said...

Thanks for giving the good informative tutorial
VenueMachine

nakchtra devi said...

Thanks for giving the good informative tutorial
pv2009

George jakzin said...

Thanks for the comments which the peoples are give here.
MoyeuvElo

Chennai said...

What a good suggestion posted by the peoples budgetorfudget

Kazris said...

Articles are really nice to read and most of the people like this
klartisan

Vijay said...

Its useful to every one and keep posting.KateRaphael 

zeollo tomo said...

Nice post. Every one should implement this one.
xnmyz

prithiv said...

All the post are very useful to implement in our life
alfredadlerlegacy

Zelina Rae said...

Thanks for giving the good informative tutorial
langelandschoolmassacre

Zhara Timothy said...

Articles are very nice…Nice comments too. w7zt

Jammy Ray said...


Information's are more innovative and nice to read it. greenfieldism

Zeenath Rae said...

Awesome ideas are given here…!
FantAziafuggony

harish agarwal said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all
c4modeloflearning

ChloeZoey said...

Articles are very nice…Nice comments too freyberghouse

Aarthi arun said...

Information's are more innovative and nice to read it.
BendaNdBake

OakleyPaisley said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all..
ipr2011

AllinOnePestControl said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all
tksxcyw

Riyash Dev said...

Simply super  comments are posted here..
clph

jack edwin said...

I am so excited while I read all the comments. MopenStudio

AmeliaEvelyn said...

goldcountrybaptist The information which you people are given are really superb..!!!

jack edwin said...

What a good suggestion posted by the peoples. MopenStudio

HMS Janitorial Service said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all
kis110

Alvin said...

What a good suggestion posted by the peoples
surgelati

Bryan Powell said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all
Arayu

CharlotteHarper said...

Information's are more innovative and nice to read it
youthtakeaction..!!!

Vishali Riyo said...

Need to implement in my blog.
wunderkammerpress

Jesira see said...

What a good suggestion posted by the peoples
VinaHotJob

Vishali Riyo said...


Thank you for this tutorial.its really informative tutorial.
Zaoxi

Gautham said...

I am so excited while I read all the comments fossilfueldesign

Omen shara said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all
LyGyyzz

Riyash Dev said...

What a good suggestion posted by the peoples SeDaySpa

bigshow said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all
ChamoTimes

John said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all
wottfood

arun kumar said...

Thanks for giving the good informative tutorial
LismoreUniversityRooms

John said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all
menurepairmen

Liza Rene said...


Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all..
jcorcoran

hollyjpepper said...

The information which you people are said here are really good..!!!


S3city

Nancyfisher11 said...

Better than average one,every ought to like this. Continue posting the articles.

buy phen375

Evita Kiley said...

What a good suggestion posted by the peoples.
azumanoforbusiness

Liza Rene said...

Thank you for this tutorial.its really informative tutorial. ehnverein

Evita Kiley said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all.. plevenon

Liza Rene said...

For my view is Really nice.
sjtchem

vaishno devi said...

Thank you for this guidance.its really informative for all
ValGalArt

Harish Dev said...

Its really nice informative tutorial,so thanks for this tutorial
DrianoStudios

John Joeban said...


I am so excited while I read all the comments.
treebound

Charlie Ila said...

The information's are really good and peoples are given superb comments
JamesAsmus

Jambari Juma said...

I am so excited while I read all the comments. twizonebr

Irfan Shamira said...

All the information's are more innovative
versasrshelpdesk

George jakzin said...

its really informative tutorial. Thank you for this tutorial .
webwizardsolutions

Kazris said...

I am really excited for read all the post
downtownjasperalabama

zeollo tomo said...

The information which you people are said here are really good..!!! PortugueseSayings

Zelina Rae said...

Nice Post and all information's are used to everybody
boucherievalens

Zhara Timothy said...

I am so excited while I read all the comments. rpheatingandcooling

harish agarwal said...

For my view is Really nice,because all peoples are giving the wonderful comments
lcxlwfgg

Jammy Ray said...


Thanks for the comments which the peoples are give here. guilcosojo

AllinOnePestControl said...

Really nice,everybody like All the Post
gamernation

HMS Janitorial Service said...

All the post are very useful to implement in our life
BrinquedodemuLher

Aarthi arun said...

Its very useful if every one should follow this. guilcosojo

Bryan Powell said...

Nice comments are posted and very useful
ChrisTeeterSculpture

jack edwin said...

I am so excited while I read all the comments.
LarevoluciondelmenosesMas

Evita Kiley said...


Beautiful post given by so many peoples.
menurepairmen

Sachin said...

Very useful to implement in Life thepopsucker.

Liza Rene said...


Articles are very nice…Nice comments too. emersondameron

John Joeban said...


Articles are very nice…Nice comments too.
ndnspeechmom

Shane warne said...

moosenoose Not only to read need to spreed every one.

Steve said...

Need to implement in my blog sqmyxx.

Jambari Juma said...


All the post are nice to read it...
kinograph


George jakzin said...


Thanks for the comments which the peoples are give here.
xnmyz

Gautham said...

Technically very well above you said babyminding.

zeollo tomo said...

I am so excited while I read all the comments. greenfieldism

Steve said...

Awesome ideas are given here budgetorfudget…!

Zhara Timothy said...


Articles are very nice…Nice comments too.
BendaNdBake

Mohamed alex said...

Nice work,keep going goldcountrybaptist

Jammy Ray said...


its really informative tutorial. Thank you for this tutorial .
MopenStudio

Daniel Grace said...

The information's are really good and peoples are given superb comments
Zaoxi

Thirsha said...

Simply super comments are posted here bayiv..

Aarthi arun said...


its really informative tutorial. Thank you for this tutorial . CuraLoop

dhanush simbu said...

Those post in the blog are very useful…..LinqPhone.com




Richard Marshal said...

The information's are really good and peoples are given superb comments
SeDaySpa

hollyjpepper said...

What a good suggestion posted by the peoples archsport

Madison Mia said...

All the information's are more innovative
LyGyyzz

jack edwin said...


Thank you for this tutorial.its really informative tutorial. klartisan

Priya said...

All the post are nice to read it...SuperJuegosFlash.com




Isaiah Elijah said...

I am really excited for read all the post
wottfood

Mohamed said...

kateraphael The information which you people are given are really superb..!!!

Sebastian Corey said...

Nice Post and all information's are used to everybody
neokolor

rithika said...

Thanks for the comments which the peoples are give here.ZeroNaInfo.com




Moha said...

fantaziafuggony Information's are more innovative and nice to read it

Rajini said...

Its useful to every one and keep posting .ChiisaiNatsu.com




Vijay said...

Must be appreciated for the articleMayInducPhat.com.

Jesira see said...

The information's are really good and peoples are given superb comments
oofeed

Omen shara said...

The information's are really good and peoples are given superb comments
getjoomlanow

Steve said...

I am so excited while I read all the comments tapchiruouvang

Mohamed alex said...

yuanlukito All the post are nice to read it...

Thirsha said...

forgrandma Thanks for the comments which the peoples are give here

hollyjpepper said...

guygarrud Really good one,every should like this

Mohamed said...

breathalyzerguide Good stuff comments here... Nice to read it

Moha said...

battlefordsskatingclub Thank you for this tutorial.its really informative tutorial.

Chennai said...

caraccidentattorneysearch Very useful to implement in Life.

ChloeZoey said...

ikzhibo Information's are more innovative and nice to read it

OakleyPaisley said...

cqzhilengshebei Keep posting the articles,useful to every one.

arun kumar said...

The information's are really good and peoples are given superb comments
oreophrynella

Namaku Keren said...

Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus
Obat Kanker Usus

Namaku Keren said...

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

teguh priyanto said...

T
B
B
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H

teguh priyanto said...

H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

teguh priyanto said...

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D

teguh priyanto said...

D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D

D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D

teguh priyanto said...

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D

teguh priyanto said...

D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D

D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D

Namaku Keren said...

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

Namaku Keren said...

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

teguh priyanto said...

A
B
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C

C
C
C
C
C
C

teguh priyanto said...

C
C
C
C
C
C
C
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
BE
BE
BE
BE
BE
BE
BE
BE
BE
BE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE

Obat kanker serviks manjur said...

TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE

Obat kanker serviks manjur said...

TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE

Namaku Keren said...

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

Namaku Keren said...

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

teguh priyanto said...

TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE

teguh priyanto said...

TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE
TE

Shane warne said...

Need to implement in my blog knoxdemocrats

Steve said...

Really good one,every should like this banjavrujcicascade

Gautham said...

Simply super comments are posted here honeinu..

Steve said...

All the post are nice to read it m-cheer...

Mohamed alex said...

Articles are very nice…Nice comments too radiocaceres

Thirsha said...

The information which you people are given are really superb sportscareersfoundation..!!!

hollyjpepper said...

Technically very well above you said.
barriodelacandelaria

Mohamed said...

Thank you for this tutorial.its really informative tutorial chiisainatsu

Moha said...

Those post in the blog are very useful…..
combo2x1

Shaun Marshaus said...

Its very useful if every one should follow this.
miguelmartino

Richard Johnson said...

Awesome ideas are given here…!
olharesinsolitos

Vincent Arokiaraj said...

Nice work,keep going.
twizonebr

Virat Kholi said...

its really informative tutorial. Thank you for this tutorial beekmanhistory

Virat Kholi said...

its really informative tutorial. Thank you for this tutorial
beekmanhistory

sasav said...

I like thee helpful info you provide inn your articles.
Safe steroids

doka said...

Excellent beat !

Pilules said...

I am actually thankful to the owner oof this web page who has shared this impressive post at att this place.
Pilules Pour Maigrir France

Clenbuterol said...

I used to be able to find good info from your articles.